Demi
Moore is an individual to be admired and respected. That is
the verdict after watching GI Jane, where she plays the first
woman trainee in the US Navy. Demi goes through a staggering
number of exhausting tests, brutal verbal and physical violence,
and essentially makes herself oblivious to what is considered
"proper" female behaviour, that to call her admirable just
doesn`t cut it. She`s one dame you should not dare mess with.
Now
I say this even as I fully agree with anyone who tells me
the training depicted here is vile, cruel, humiliating, and
certainly not for us so-called sensible people. If this movie
were real life, and I knew Demi Moore, I`d try anything to
dissuade her from such a career, because, frankly, the less
people who are emotionally and mentally blunted by a career
in warfare, the better. But this is a movie, so I would call
Moore a brave soul to take on this brutal role. And that brutal
role is what ultimately saves this movie, which does contain
a few noticeable flaws. Demi Moore is not an actress who I`m
usually interested in, but after seeing this, I've garnered
a whole new perspective on her, and understand, in this film
anyway, her true integrity.
Moore
plays, as I said, the first female trainee in the US Navy,
and this is possible due to the political manoeuvring of a
Texas senator, played by Anne Bancroft. Moore's lover has
objections to her entry, mainly because he wonders why a nice
girl like her would want to get into a mess like the Navy.
But Moore is unrelenting in her wish to get in, especially
considering that she was not allowed to participate in the
Gulf War, and so wants to prove to herself that she would
be capable of a similar task if it arose.
But
if she wants to pass the test, she has to withstand everything
thrown in her path, especially the presence of the Master
Chief, who, in the grand tradition of movie drill instructors,
is a cruel and heartless sort. Interestingly enough, he is
also a knowledgeable literary man, quoting D. H. Lawrence
to his inferiors, although I doubt most of them would know
that. They would assume Master Chief is a master at being
nuts, as he talks about how birds would rather die than take
pity for themselves. In other words, Master Chief doesn't
care about your pain. He'd rather see you quit in humiliation
if you can't survive the harsh, brutal nature that is war.
And he definitely would like to see Moore quit, on the first
day if necessary.
But
it doesn`t happen. In fact, Moore does such a valiant job,
she is the target of much resentment. One of the troops in
her own group disregards the concept of teamwork by not helping
her up a wall during an exercise, and by doing so, creates
a black mark on Moore`s efforts. The men in general deliver
the typical verbal garbage so common among the macho, redneck
variety, when faced with womenkind. And when word leaks out
to the public about the extraordinary achievements of this
lone woman in a pack of wolves, high-powered officials will
do anything to make sure she doesn't make it. For you see,
it's one thing to form an impression of women participating
fully in the military, and create an easy solution to appease
the feminist vote, but quite another when a woman actually
does a good job beyond the confines of politics.
Besides
the anti-female abuse Moore takes, there is the abuse that
naturally goes with the job.. And it takes no small amount
of bravery for an actor to submit to the sorts of things shown
here. There are many exercises in the water, including a scene
where the people are held down while continuous streams of
water are poured on their face, essentially to slowly remove
the fear one naturally has when faced with the possibility
of drowning. There are numerous war games involved, including
the film's centerpiece, where Moore`s group is "captured"
by enemies and are tortured. The idea of course is to submit
the troops to as much agony as possible to prepare for the
possible reality. When Moore is the next to be tortured, it
goes far beyond the rules of the game (which are violent enough)
in to the ultimate action taken by Master Chief to get rid
of her, which results in the most violent scene in the movie,
where the two of them basically beat the pulp out of each
other. This may disturb people who understandably can`t accept
seeing women being beaten up by a man, but it does finally
show a woman who can handle pretty much anything.
The
flaws of the movie basically come down to what happens at
the end, where we are suddenly thrown into an action sequence
which does not belong; which removes itself from the confines
of the training exercises and into real warfare. To be honest,
I think it is a pretty ridiculous transition, as if the director,
Ridley Scott, figured there had to be a war sequence, to satisfy
the (male) action fans who wanted to see some real action,
instead of all that nonsense about women`s equality. If a
woman (or any non-action director) handled this, that person
would probably not worry about such things - it would be just
as good to see her finish the training. We know she is good
enough already.
But
Scott still does at least allow three-dimensional women to
participate fully in an action film, as he proved in the much-better
Thelma and Louise. And the role Demi Moore is allowed to play
is a pretty powerful one, because it shows us that there really
should not be any problem with any person doing what they
want to. Not as if a sensible person should have to be taught
that from a Hollywood movie, but then again there are a lot
of insensible people out there who probably couldn`t make
the effort to learn it any other way.
David
Macdonald
David
Macdonald's Movie Reviews
|